She Came to Me Review: Unconventional Romance

She Came to Me Review:

In the world of cinema, we often encounter films that defy expectations and leave audiences pondering. “She Came to Me” directed by Rebecca Miller, is one such movie, bringing together a pedigreed cast and an audacious script that promises a unique cinematic experience. This blog post explores the eccentric journey of “She Came to Me,” blending flimsy, fanciful, and far-fetched notions into a screwball New York rom-com.

An Unexpected Ensemble:

One of the most remarkable aspects of “She Came to Me” is the unlikely pairing of a wildly convoluted script with an ensemble cast of exceptional talent. Writer-director Rebecca Miller, known for her previous works such as “The Ballad of Jack and Rose” and “Maggie’s Plan,” managed to assemble an impressive lineup, including Peter Dinklage, Anne Hathaway, and the ever-charming Marisa Tomei. The mere presence of these acclaimed actors in such a peculiar project sparks curiosity.

The Unpredictable Plot:

The film introduces us to the world of Steven Lauddem, a morose and neurotic opera composer portrayed by Peter Dinklage. Steven finds himself struggling with writer’s block just as a commission deadline looms menacingly over his career. He’s been down this road before, and another failure could spell doom for his once-brilliant career. His wife, Patricia (played by Anne Hathaway), is a fascinating character in her own right, a meticulous neat freak who unexpectedly finds herself drawn to the world of religion, both as a destination and a lifestyle.

A Romantic Twist:

Enter Katrina, a character brought to life by Marisa Tomei, who is an itinerant tugboat operator—a role that seems uniquely chosen. However, what sets Katrina apart is her peculiar romanticism, bordering on stalking tendencies. Steven’s chance encounter with her in a bar leads to an affair that reignites his creative spark. He transforms his opera to reflect their passionate encounter, albeit with a gruesome twist, as Katrina’s on-stage counterpart becomes a murderer, earning comparisons to “a female ‘Sweeney Todd.'”

A Starry-Eyed Subplot:

As the film progresses, a subplot takes center stage, featuring a starry-eyed romance between Julian (Evan Ellison), Patricia’s biracial son from her previous marriage, and Tereza (Harlow Jane), the daughter of Patricia and Steven’s immigrant housekeeper, Magdalena (Joanna Kulig of “Cold War”). The budding romance between the teenagers takes an unexpected turn when Magdalena’s husband and Tereza’s stepfather, Trey (Brian d’Arcy James), a court stenographer and amateur justice warrior with a penchant for Civil War reenactments, becomes a protective figure. His sudden desire to have Julian arrested in the midst of the film’s whimsical vibe feels like a plot device rather than a well-earned story development.

A Dash of Rebellion:

The young lovers, Julian and Tereza, find themselves on the run, reminiscent of a modern-day “Romeo and Juliet.” Their escape is facilitated by an unlikely trio: Steven, Katrina, and Magdalena, resulting in a peculiar and, at times, eccentric journey. Even a visit to one of Trey’s Civil War reenactments adds an extra layer of quirkiness to the film’s narrative.

Mixed Feelings and Overwhelming Eccentricity:

While “She Came to Me” is undoubtedly a cinematic rollercoaster, it has divided audiences with its peculiar and whimsical tone. Some viewers embrace its eccentricity, appreciating its unpredictability, while others find the film’s far-fetched storylines and characters hard to connect with. The film’s handling of mental illness also leaves room for debate.

Bright Spots Amid Eccentricity:

The film does have its moments. It captures the Brooklyn settings well, and the actors give their best, despite the challenges of portraying eccentric and surface-level characters. A stroke of luck in the form of Bruce Springsteen writing “Addicted to Romance,” a captivating song that closes the film, adds a touch of emotion to the narrative.


“She Came to Me” is a cinematic journey through love, art, and eccentricity, where the unexpected becomes the norm. While it may not cater to everyone’s taste, it undeniably offers a unique and unforgettable cinematic experience. In a world where not every film can be a universal hit, this quirky rom-com defies expectations, making it a subject of debate and discussion.

Cinema thrives on diversity, and “She Came to Me” certainly adds a dose of unpredictability to the mix. Whether you embrace its eccentricity or find it far-fetched, the film stands as a testament to the power of creativity and individuality in the world of storytelling.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *